Until recently, the typical insurance shopper might enter “affordable car insurance in my city” into Google and get a list of quote tools, blog articles on insurance coverage, and business listings. In the age of Google search, independent insurance agencies built their websites around keywords to show up in these results. Ultimately, a website served as a business card and brochure in one, helping direct potential clients to a conversation with an agent.
But AI is changing how the web works. In the world of “zero-click search”—where web users can get information without clicking a link to a website—AI tools built into search engines can answer questions, provide education, and even make recommendations for insurance carriers, all on the search screen.
The latest data on web trends shows 71% of web users are using AI for search, and web traffic for most sites is declining 20% to 50%. As more people turn to AI-powered search, agencies need to explore new ways to use their websites to generate leads and give clients what they are looking for. Agencies can adapt to the new AI landscape with some changes to their inbound prospecting strategies.
Rethink how your agency website attracts end-insureds
Despite the changing world of the web, insurance agency websites continue to be effective tools for reaching insurance shoppers. The key is to show up where people are looking for information and to offer something worth looking at.
Start by recognizing how content has changed. Search now works with natural language instead of keywords and search terms. Google users can type full questions into a search browser and receive AI snippets that answer questions before they even see links to visit a site.
AI search engines prioritize content that is clear, authoritative, and empathetic. To appear in AI search, focus on educating end-insureds and owning the advisor role.
Add short, authoritative sections that directly answer the questions you hear from clients every day. Help clients understand their risks, coverage options, and decisions. These help AI models identify your agency as a credible source for insurance guidance.
Tailor your content to the style of AI search
You might already be familiar with the “voice” of AI: pointed questions, concise responses, bulleted lists, and downloadable guides. These should be style cues for your web content. Create new webpages and blogs with this style in mind and update your best performing content to make sure it continues to do well.
By working with the content formats that AI already prefers, you can make it easier for your content to show up where you want it to. These formats help AI tools pull cleaner excerpts from your site, cite you as a source, and treat your insurance agency as an expert.
To position your content for AI search, include:
-
Definitions and explanations: Clients might ask to define insurance terms like the difference between a premium and a deductible to better understand their policy. Clearly explain insurance terms to position your site for citation.
-
FAQs: Because AI uses natural language, insurance shoppers can pose a question and get a detailed answer. Covering the questions you often hear can help get you noticed as an expert.
-
Authoritative information: Demonstrate your expertise in your line of work and fill your website with that type of information. You can use your firsthand perspective on what market changes are affecting rates or what coverage clients need in your specific area.
-
SEO: AI is important, but traditional search still matters, too. Continue to follow good search engine optimization and content marketing practices.
Reach potential insurance clients with localized content
AI search tools are pulling information from across the web. Search queries on nationwide trends or general insurance information can come from anywhere. But it’s not getting the information your clients need most: expert insights about what’s happening with rates and coverage in your own backyard.
Insurance clients trust their agents because of the personalized expertise they’re able to provide. Local insurance agents know what claims are common, what similar clients are paying for their coverage, and specific risk factors clients need to consider—like a higher chance of hail damage or business needs in a particular part of town. An AI search tool is less likely to have access to any of this information.
While you’re thinking locally, make sure AI search can find you in other local lists. Update your Google business profile, seek out local business listings, and strengthen your existing community partnerships. Your website has a worldwide reach, but your business’ footprint is much smaller.
How new lead prospecting strategies can drive your insurance agency forward
The shift in search is a signal to update your website’s content, but it also presents an opportunity to take a closer look at how clients move through your agency’s entire digital ecosystem.
When people discover information in new ways, their paths to becoming a lead change as well. Understanding those paths gives your agency a clearer view of what drives engagement and where new opportunities emerge.
Every client interaction produces data that shows what efforts drive engagement and what needs adjustment. Metrics such as open and response rates, campaign conversions, producer follow-up activity, and client retention all tell part of the story.
Tools like form analytics, CRM tags and notes, and multi-touch attribution can provide those insights by revealing how clients first connect with you and what prompts them to take the next step. As AI search reshapes how people find insurance information, the patterns behind your incoming leads might shift.
Keeping a firm grasp on these signals helps your agency adjust in real time and maintain a strong prospecting engine, even as traffic redistributes across different channels.
AI tools will continue to reshape how consumers search, shop, and communicate. Agencies that continue to evolve their own strategies and take advantage of the latest tools will be able to adapt as those changes happen. Partnering with a technology provider that delivers reliable data, clear insight, and continuous innovation ensures your team stays informed, efficient, and ready for what’s next.
Key takeaways:
-
In the world of “zero-click search,” web users can get information without clicking a link to a website.
-
AI search engines prioritize content that is clear, authoritative, and empathetic. Focus on educating end-insureds and owning the advisor role.
-
Adopt the content formats that AI prefers: FAQs with definitions, bulleted lists, and one-pagers.
-
Find a foothold with AI search by providing content that your specific clients want and only you have, like niche or local information.
-
Use your data to understand how clients are finding you. Tools like using form analytics, CRM tags and notes, and multi-touch attribution can help develop these insights.